Chat with us, powered by LiveChat

Healthy Probiotic Frosting to Reduce Sugar for Kids (& Adults)

Healthy frosting sounds like an oxymoron, I know, but it can be reality and makes an amazing fruit pizza, for starters. It has no white sugar, and your kids will love to make it themselves!

Yogurt and probiotic rich yogurt cream cheese frosting in a bowl and on a fruit tart.

Frosting can really divide a relationship, you know.

There’s inch-thick versus paper-thin, there’s so sweet it’s practically straight sugar vs. cream cheese vs. whipped cream fluff with almost no taste.

And in my husband’s book, there’s the cake with no frosting at all!

Cake With or Without Frosting

Who does that? A whole cake with no frosting? That’s what we used to make him when we were dating, just a vanilla box mix, no frosting.

He’s a vanilla kind of guy in every way.

For better or for worse (and probably worse now that I know more about sugar), my mom’s homemade frosting actually won him over.

Healthy probiotic frosting kids will love to make.

We in the family all like to frost our baked goods, so we kind of like that dad likes frosting now. It’s delicious with its almond flavoring, truly the magic ingredient.

But. We are a Kitchen Stewardship® family, and frosting that is mostly sugar, albeit using plenty of healthy butter, is not something that we should be seeking out.

Today’s recipe was my solution to healthy + delicious frosting.

It combines thick, probiotic-rich yogurt cheese with minimal sweetener and almond extract… Perfection.

Healthy probiotic frosting on a knife with a blueberry tart in the background.

The Benefits of Yogurt Cheese

Yogurt cheese is a lot like cream cheese but with only one ingredient and of course probiotics, which are always helpful. For a whole cup of yogurt cheese, we only use one tablespoon of pure maple syrup, tops, which means the sugar and carb count stays very low.

In fact, for kids like mine, who are used to eating plain yogurt with zero sweetener, we actually can get away with pretty much no sweetener at all. Think of it – there’s already usually a good bit of sugar in whatever baked good you’re topping. We don’t need to slather pure sweet on top and mask all the good flavors we’ve worked to get in the middle.

The best part, in my opinion, is that once you’ve made this recipe once or twice, you won’t even need the recipe again. It’s super easy to just eye it up, guess and check, and taste until you love it.

This is a great recipe for the kids to make. Let them experiment with ratios and sweetness. It will foster creativity while teaching them life skills.

#LifeSkillsNow Summer Camp is Back for Season Three!

Get a free family pass to the #LifeSkillsNow Season Three virtual summer camp!

LSN register now

Get 13 skills workshops right away when you register!

Prepare your kids for life with solid skills for living that aren’t taught in school!


Probiotic cream cheese frosting in a bowl and on a fruit tart.

How to Use Healthy Creamy Frosting

So what to put almond flavored probiotic yogurt cheese frosting ON? Just about anything will work.

It goes great on any cake or cupcake that would work for a birthday cake and is especially great on things with spices like cinnamon, cloves, and nutmeg. That means any sort of applesauce, carrot, or pumpkin muffin is a good fit.

And cookies? Why not! Particularly a butter or sugar cookie that doesn’t have a lot of flavor in itself, really does need a little zip in the frosting. This frosting works great!

Try these:

  1. Easy Pumpkin Muffins
  2. Gluten-free Allergy-Friendly Pumpkin Muffins
  3. Applesauce Einkorn Muffins
  4. Easy Healthy Pumpkin Cookies
  5. Gluten-free Soft Pumpkin Cookies

This frosting is already incorporated in some family favorite recipes like our egg-free, grain-free first birthday cake (a frozen pumpkin fudge) and our healthy whole grain fruit pizza.

One year for my son’s birthday we used half sugary frosting (Mom’s famous!) and half probiotic frosting, and NO food coloring, just cute superheroes on sticks!

Superman birthday cupcakes with healthy probiotic cream cheese frosting.

The only bad news ironically is that my husband doesn’t like this one! He’s just not a fan of cream cheese, so even though he really does like plain yogurt, this is tangier than he prefers. Bummer, right?

I’m thinking if I took the time to blend it with some thawed frozen berries, however, he’d be all about it. Worth trying for a future post, right?

Finally, here’s that recipe that you can pretty much eye up and memorize after you try it once!

clock clock iconcutlery cutlery iconflag flag iconfolder folder iconinstagram instagram iconpinterest pinterest iconfacebook facebook iconprint print iconsquares squares iconheart heart iconheart solid heart solid icon

Healthy Probiotic Frosting to Reduce Sugar for Kids (& Adults)

5 Stars 4 Stars 3 Stars 2 Stars 1 Star 5 from 1 review
  • Author: Katie Kimball
  • Prep Time: 5
  • Total Time: 5 minutes
  • Category: Dessert
  • Cuisine: American


A solution to healthy + delicious in frosting. It combines thick, probiotic-rich yogurt cheese with minimal sweetener and almond extract… Perfection.


  • 1 c. yogurt cheese
  • 1/21 tsp. almond extract
  • 1 tsp. – 1 Tbs. maple syrup, to taste

ship kroger


Whip up until smooth, and be sure to taste and adjust as necessary!

That’s it!

I generally don’t measure anything but just pour a bit of extract into the cap and dump it in, then drizzle a wee bit of maple syrup on top. I really do think that it is sustainable and pretty yummy without any sweetener, and it’s very easy to reduce carbs further by using stevia drops. NuStevia even has flavored stevia that could switch up your taste sensations easily!


RELATED: How to use stevia liquid


* Color this frosting pink by adding some juice from thawed, frozen raspberries or strawberries.

* Add flavor by stirring in pure fruit jam or pureed fresh or frozen thawed berries of any kind.

* Try other natural colors with real food as shown here.

  • Need a little help getting healthy food on the table every day? Real Plans takes the stress out of meal planning and puts the nourishing food BACK on your table. There’s a plan for every diet type, including GAPS, Paleo, AIP, Whole30, vegetarian and more! You remain totally in control: use your own recipes, accept theirs, and teach the system what your family likes…Check out how powerful it is here!

Some Quality Probiotics

Some of these I’ve used, some I’m planning to use, and some have been recommended by friends and professionals alike. It’s good to remember a few things about probiotics: 1. People should get different colonies of probiotics, so switching brands/strains every so often (6 weeks?) is good practice. 2. What works great for one person’s needs doesn’t always work for another.  I’ve personally tried:
  • Just Thrive Probiotics – this one can be taken during antibiotics and not be rendered ineffective, which almost all other probiotics are! It’s the top-recommended probiotic overall by Paleo Mom Sarah Ballantyne. 😮 (Be sure to use the code Katie15 for 15% off; also found on Amazon and from Perfect Supplements where you can use the coupon KS10 for 10% off!)
  • Seed Daily Synbiotic – the new player in the field but recommended by superstars like Chris Kresser for its unique probiotic/prebiotic synergy. Here’s my full review including a number of surprises for my thinking and a 15% off code!
  • Note: If you’re struggling with digestion, especially constipation, or you feel like you really need to populate your gut with healthy probiotics, I would recommend Saccharomyces Boulardii in addition to any other you choose (except any above which include this strain). Saccharomyces Boulardii is research-proven to get through the digestive tract without being killed, which is rare. 
  • Balance One probiotics with a unique time-release formula (use the code KITCHENS15 at either Balance One’s site or even Amazon to save 15% either place! Wow! Use the code at checkout on Amazon btw.)

For Little Ones (we use all of these):

  • Mary Ruth’s liquid probiotic is a liquid probiotic that doesn’t need to be refrigerated and tastes like…nothing! It’s my new favorite for administering to kids! (Use code KCRF15 for 15% off!)
  • WellBelly by WellFuture (9 strains of probiotics in apple and banana carrier – it’s a powder)
  • Buddies in my Belly probiotic powder (2 strains of probiotics + potato starch carrier and prebiotics) or chewable tablets
Recommended by experts I trust: Unless otherwise credited, photos are owned by the author or used with a license from Canva or Deposit Photos.

3 thoughts on “Healthy Probiotic Frosting to Reduce Sugar for Kids (& Adults)”

  1. Ginny Barrett

    I have made one made yogurt and yogurt cheese. Question, can you freeze yogurt cheese to make icing when you need or even freeze the icing o use another time?

  2. You should look into making frosting with whipping cream in the food processor. You are in complete control of the type and amount of sugar. As a bonus, you can powder freeze dried fruit to add to it. We have made strawberry, but not ventured to other flavors. Thanks for all the great posts and encouragement.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe rating 5 Stars 4 Stars 3 Stars 2 Stars 1 Star

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.