I know turkey is the quintessential Thanksgiving meal, but who says it has to be stuck there? I can’t believe it took me so long to figure this out, but I finally realized that if I buy a couple frozen whole turkey breasts a year, I’m doing something very healthy and very frugal (even if it’s NOT November!). Here’s why:
- Turkey is a Super Food – read its awesome nutritional profile here.
- It’s actually really easy to roast a turkey, not something you need to relegate to a “company meal”. Just follow the directions on the package (having a meat thermometer helps though).
- You get style points from the family for serving what looks like a super-fancy meal, but actually it takes less prep time than a lot of from-scratch casseroles and soups. Choose a Sunday or a random surprise day to serve the roast turkey.
Meal Stretcher Tip: Serve with lots of sides to encourage big eaters to take less turkey; then you have more leftovers for sandwishes! - At $2/lb (or even less, sometimes down to 99 cents/lb) on sale, the turkey breast is less expensive than a lot of other cuts of meat. Why think of it as a luxury?
Who needs lunchmeat? Leftover turkey breast, first of all, makes FAR superior sandwiches compared to processed meat. Plus, no matter how you buy your lunchmeat (deli counter or packages), you’re still going to spend around $3-5/lb on the stuff. Remember that the little packages are often less than half a pound, so even though it may only be $1.67 or something, you have to do the math to compare pound for pound. (And might I add that turkey off the bone is real food, whereas lunchmeat is processed with salt and nitrites, a known carcinogen.) Our family uses a lot of leftovers for lunches, whereas I know a lot of families, especially those wtih schoolchildren, rely on lunchmeat regularly. I can’t recommend heartily enough using real meat, either chicken or turkey, to cut down on your kids’ nitrite/nitrate load. Train their palates to appreciate real food, and try to cut down on the processed stuff whenever possible.
- Yes, you’re paying for the bones. But I’ve learned to use ANY bones around to make stock, which is so easy and packed with nutrients. Just toss the carcass in the pot immediately after picking the meat off the night of your supper.

I don’t usually use turkey broth as a base for soups, since people expect the familiar taste of chicken broth, but it’s perfect for cooking a rice dish or going half/half with chicken or beef broth for soup. I also freeze it in ice cube trays, and I can use it in recipes that call for a half cup or cup, as well as to bulk up leftovers that need a little moisture for reheating.
Added Bonus: This little step of making broth really makes the turkey worth it – free broth!
Watch for turkey breasts to go on sale, especially after the fall/winter holidays as stores are trying to get rid of their overstock, and around Easter time.
Now I want a turkey sandwich. With Farmer’s Market lettuce and homemade mayo. Mmmm, drooling on my keyboard. I better go have breakfast instead!
Join Frugal Fridays at Life as MOM and Fight Back Friday at Food Renegade for more great frugal and real food tips. Also see Homemaker Mondays at 11th Heaven’s Homemaking Haven.
I’d love to see more of you! Sign up for an email subscription or grab my reader feed.
If you missed the last Monday Mission, click here.
Kitchen Stewardship is dedicated to balancing God’s gifts of time, health, earth and money. If you feel called to such a mission, read more at Mission, Method, and Mary and Martha Moments.
More on turkey:
Other How-To Posts that may interest you:
Photo source: FotoosVanRobin


















As a matter of fact, I just had some noodle soup using turkey broth I made recently–from the bones of a turkey I cooked a few months ago and froze!
And the other night, I made gravy from some more of the broth and cooked chicken tenders in it. I served it with noodles.
It was only recently that I realized I could throw a few ‘after Thanksgiving sale’ turkey breasts (and one small turkey) in my freezer to use whenever. We all need to get out of that “Thanksgiving Only” mindset, especially with modern kitchens and equipment that make cooking so much easier. Roast beef is another ‘special dinner’ meat I will make as a weeknight meal and for sandwiches later!
mom2fur’s last blog post..Frugal Friday: CC warning
[Reply to this comment]
We *love* turkey at our house. (I especially love it because I’m allergic to chicken, and I kinda like the whole poultry thing!)
I always keep my eyes open for whole fresh good quality (not chemically loaded) turkeys – year round! – and snap them up if they go on a good sale. Just got one about a month ago for something ridiculous like 90 cents a pound.
But, always cheap at our local store – from a local reputatble grower, even! – turkey thighs and drumsticks – SUPER cheap. The kids LOVE them roasted, and I take any leftovers, debone, and then freeze. Makes wonderful turkey salad for sandwiches.
Yummy!
Great post!
dina’s last blog post..Tortilla de Patata
[Reply to this comment]
Katie Reply:
July 17th, 2009 at 4:39 pm
Super – all great points! I am still working on moving toward the “high quality” poultry and finding affordable sources. Thanks for chiming in!
[Reply to this comment]
Hello,
I don’t buy lunch meat either. I do the same as you. I just roasted a Turkey Breast this week. Cook turkey freezes well too.
Have a blessed week end,
Elizabeth
Elizabeth Quigley’s last blog post..Finer Things Friday
[Reply to this comment]